Pithing needle how does it work

If someone is acting while the ability is on the stack, it's already been activated. It would stop Lightning Storm 's second ability from being activated, though, because it's the spell that's on the stack, not the ability. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more.

How does Pithing Needle work with abilities on the stack? Ask Question. Asked 3 years ago. Active 3 years ago. Viewed times. Example: Enemy activates Teferi, Hero of Dominaria 's ability.

I cast Whir of Invention in response. The stack starts to resolve, and my Whir of Invention grabs me my Pithing Needle. I name Teferi, Hero of Dominaria with my needle. What happens? Improve this question. Arcanist Lupus Shadow Z.

The answers do address your question, but I feel I should point out another part of how the needle works: Once each player has passed and let the needle enter the battlefield, a card will be named and "pithed" before anyone has a chance to play anything else. There are stories about people in tournaments who call a judge, and ask "Can I name X with this?

At that point there is nothing the opponent can do about all the now useless Y in his battlefield. For completeness' sake, the ideal move is to grab Needle while Teferi himself is still on the stack. Add a comment. Active Oldest Votes.

A continuous effect may be generated by the static ability of an object. Activating Activated Abilities Improve this answer. Community Bot 1. Hackworth Hackworth Pithing Needle also doesn't care about what type of card, it can be a land can name fetches, Wastelands , Nephalia Drownyards to make them only tap for mana if possible , Artifacts, Creatures, Planeswalkers, Enchantments and even Instants or Sorceries!

Let's look at one imprtant instant in Modern, Lightning Storm. If Lightning Storm goes on the stack, after being needled, that means it only deals 3 damage, rather than being allowed to add more charge counters to make the damage higher. Man, it's not like Needling targets can get any weirder right?

So let's continue this. Let's say for some reason your opponent is playing Underworld Connections , you can name Underworld Connections if you want, but it doesn't help you. They can still tap said land for the ability of drawing a card. Instead, we have to go a step further down the line, and name the land instead.

For an even further annoyance, let's complicate a board-state some. Opponent just ultimates Koth the Hammer , and casts Blood Moon. Not only can you not name the Emblem because it doesn't technically exist , but if the opponent has non-basic mountains, you need to start naming non-basics in addition to basic mountains to avoid the damage! So a Blood Moon'd Arid Mesa can be named so it can't tap for damage, but it will still tap for the Red mana it provides now.

I feel this is a tad unfair for the card that has so much upside, and it should be a little bit higher use in decks, the number per deck is fair, but the number of decks using is not. It's playable in any deck's sideboard, and can sometimes just win you a match. Hopefully moving forward, when deckbuilding, you'll consider the one card that'll fix up a fair number of your matchups and toss at least one poor little Pithing Needle into that sideboard of yours.

In this article I will explain the strategy behind my very odd but calculated mono deck. It is much like a dance and you are the lead. The name of the game is card draw and never letting them build a Prices update once daily at 9am eastern standard time. Prices provided by TCGplayer. It's created for you to track your collection while knowing its day-to-day value.

Create an account today. Chat with us via Twitter or Email. All rights reserved. All Magic Sets Articles. What IS a mana ability? Other Activated Abilities Once again here's the rules on an activated ability which are actually simpler to understand : " How common is Pithing Needle in Modern?

My Monoph0nik 0nyx Deck mono black control In this article I will explain the strategy behind my very odd but calculated mono deck.